Harry Shum Jr. and pro partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated from Dancing With the Stars in the season 35 semifinals on Tuesday, Nov. 17, even though they earned two perfect scores and finished the night tied for first on the judges' leaderboard. The couple scored 60 out of 60 but did not collect enough viewer votes to reach next week's finale, according to ABC News and The Hollywood Reporter. Five couples now move on to the Nov. 24 finale.
Who was eliminated on Dancing With the Stars in the semifinals?
Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were the couple sent home in the Week 10 semifinals. ABC News reports that six couples returned to the ballroom on Nov. 17 and each performed one ballroom routine and one Latin routine, which meant one pair would miss the five-couple finale.
The result landed hard because Shum and Johnson had been treated as frontrunners for most of the fall. E! News described them as leaving "after 10 weeks of fierce competition," and The Hollywood Reporter called it a "stunning elimination" for the second week in a row. The week before, Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy, Johnson's husband, were sent home on Grammy Night, per ABC News.
How did Harry Shum Jr. go home with a perfect score?
They went home because DWTS does not rank couples on judges' scores alone. The Hollywood Reporter explains that the couple with the lowest combined total of judges' scores and viewer votes is eliminated each week, so a perfect 60 can still lose if the audience splits its votes elsewhere.
That is what happened on Tuesday. Shum and Johnson tied Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov at 60, but the viewer tally pushed them to the bottom. Co-host Julianne Hough offered a theory on air, as quoted by E! News: "Sometimes when people are doing so well in the competition, people don't necessarily vote, because they think you're doing so well with scores."
Hough's comment points to a real quirk of the format. Fans of a couple who top the leaderboard every week can assume their favorite is safe and spread their votes to someone who looks more vulnerable. In a semifinal with only six couples, a small shift like that can decide who goes home.
What did Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson dance in the semifinals?
They performed a paso doble and a quickstep, and both earned 30 out of 30. TODAY lists the first routine as a paso doble to Rihanna's "We Found Love" featuring Calvin Harris and the second as a quickstep to "Valerie."
The quickstep carried extra meaning. E! News says it was a tribute to Shum's years on Glee, and The Hollywood Reporter reports the couple danced to the version of "Valerie" performed on the show by Naya Rivera, his late co-star, whom Shum shouted out after the routine.
The run was also notable for what Johnson danced through. E! News reports she competed in the quarterfinals with a broken nose. "Dance is a physical contact sport, and I want to always represent dancers as athletes," she told the outlet after the Nov. 10 episode.
What did Harry Shum Jr. say to Jenna Johnson after the elimination?
Shum thanked Johnson and praised how she handled pressure from outside the show. "I want to say you have been dealing with everything with grace, with the noise outside," he told her, according to E! News, adding that she taught him "the things that I have only dreamed of to learn" and calling the season "one of the most beautiful experiences."
E! News connects the "noise outside" line to a storyline that followed the couple this season: Chmerkovskiy, Johnson's husband and Dewan's partner, was suspended for one week this season over online comments. Shum did not spell out what he meant, so his remark is best read as a thank-you to his partner rather than a statement about that episode.
For Johnson, the exit ends a bid for a third Mirrorball. E! News notes she previously won season 26 with figure skater Adam Rippon and season 33 with The Bachelor star Joey Graziadei.
Who is in the Dancing With the Stars season 35 finale?
Five couples made the finale: Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas, Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach, Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik, and Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold, according to ABC News.
The semifinal scores show how close the race is. Per The Hollywood Reporter's leaderboard, Glenn finished with 60, Higgins with 59, Frech with 57, Ali with 55 and Wood with 48. Frech earned his first perfect score of the season for a jive to "Footloose," and Ali received her first 10 from judge Carrie Ann Inaba for a cha cha.
Wood finished last with the judges in both rounds yet survived, which is the mirror image of Shum's exit and another reminder that fan votes carry real weight at this stage. Heatline has followed Higgins' run closely, including the debate over her tango and the "fix" rumors earlier this season.
When is the DWTS season 35 finale and how does voting work?
The finale airs Tuesday, Nov. 24, at 8 p.m. ET / 5 p.m. PT on ABC and Disney+. TODAY reports the three-hour finale will air live across the country for the first time, and the five remaining couples will each perform three routines: a judges' choice dance, an instant dance and a freestyle.
The live coast-to-coast broadcast matters for voting. The Hollywood Reporter notes that voting normally happens only during the East Coast airing, so West Coast fans have had to watch early to take part. Viewers can cast up to 10 votes per couple through ABC's website and up to 10 by text, and voting closes shortly after the final performance.
What happens next for Harry Shum Jr. and the DWTS cast?
The season is not quite over for the eliminated couples. Dancing With the Stars: Live is heading out on a 60-show North American tour in 2027, as People reported in October and Heatline covered at the time. As of Nov. 18, Heatline had not seen any report on whether Shum or Johnson will join the tour.
For now, the semifinal result reshapes the finale. With one of the strongest couples gone, the Mirrorball race is open, and judges' favorites Glenn and Higgins head into the last week as the pairs to beat on paper.
