Actor Daniel Roebuck is disputing director Chris Columbus' account of why Roebuck was fired from the role of Marv in Home Alone. On a podcast released Tuesday, Nov. 17, Columbus called the original Marv actor "just awful" after a "horrible" screen test with Joe Pesci; Roebuck, who was not named but has long said he was that actor, told Entertainment Weekly and Page Six that no such screen test ever happened. Daniel Stern went on to play Marv in the 1990 holiday classic.
What did Chris Columbus say about firing an actor from Home Alone?
Columbus said the original Marv was "the only person I ever had to fire." Speaking on the Nov. 17 episode of the Wildmen podcast, co-hosted by his son Brendan Columbus and actor Dylan Sprouse, the 68-year-old director said the studio initially would not pay for Stern, according to People.
"I conceived of Dan Stern and Joe Pesci in this movie as the bad guys. And they said, 'You only get one.' So I said, 'Okay, let's go with Pesci,'" Columbus said. He then described the replacement casting: "We did a screen test and they were horrible. I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful."
Columbus said he told the actor, "We'll work together at some point," People reports, but that never happened. Page Six adds that Columbus said the firing came after four days.
Who was originally cast as Marv in Home Alone?
Daniel Roebuck was originally cast as Marv before Daniel Stern took over the role. Columbus did not name him on the podcast, but Roebuck has spoken publicly about the firing for years, People and Entertainment Weekly note.
EW reports the casting shuffle was documented in a 2019 episode of Netflix's The Movies That Made Us, and Roebuck discussed it on the What a Character! podcast in 2023. In a 2024 appearance on Anchor Bay Entertainment's The Plank, he said, "I was just a pawn in a game to get Daniel Stern," adding that he was told he was the second choice and that he was paid for the role, per People.
Roebuck, now 63, built a long career after the setback. EW notes his credits include The Fugitive and River's Edge, and he told the outlet the opportunities he got "because I was not in Home Alone were extraordinary."
What is Daniel Roebuck disputing?
Roebuck disputes the claim that he and Pesci ever filmed a screen test. "They never rolled a camera on Joe Pesci and I," he told EW. "There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that's impossible. I sat with Joe Pesci for one afternoon."
He gave Page Six a similar account: "They never, ever, ever filmed me and Joe Pesci together. I never, ever filmed anything with Joe Pesci." Page Six reports that Roebuck suggested Columbus may be misremembering what happened.
Roebuck also pushed back on the "no chemistry" explanation he says he was given. Harry and Marv share only a short scene before the slapstick begins, he told EW: "I reminded him that the characters literally spent a two-page scene together, and after that they were both being hit in the face with nails. So it didn't really matter what the chemistry was." To Page Six, he put it more bluntly: "How horrible could I have been if I was the second choice for a $35 million movie?"
Both outlets said they reached out to Columbus' representatives, and neither had published a response from him.
How does Daniel Roebuck feel about Chris Columbus now?
Roebuck says he is hurt but holds no grudge. "It hurts my heart, and it hurts my heart that every Christmas I have to deal with this," he told Page Six, adding, "I'm certainly a man of forgiveness. So I never held a grudge against him for firing me."
He was also careful to praise the director. "I have enormous respect for Chris Columbus. I've enjoyed all of his movies," Roebuck told EW. "But I find these comments troubling." He even left the door open to working together, telling the outlet, "I think he'd find me to be a good actor and a nice person." Roebuck told Page Six he has had no contact with Columbus since the firing.
What did Joe Pesci's team say?
A representative for Pesci declined to weigh in on the dispute. The rep told EW that the actor is "respectful of all talent he works with as well as the crew that brings these projects to life," and "would never participate in gossip like this."
That matters because Pesci, now 83, is the only other person who could settle the screen-test question firsthand. Without his account or footage, readers are left with two conflicting memories of a few days on a set more than 35 years ago. Columbus' version is a quick anecdote told for laughs on a podcast; Roebuck's is a detailed rebuttal he has given consistently in several interviews.
Why does the Home Alone casting story keep coming back?
It resurfaces because Home Alone returns every holiday season, and Roebuck says the questions come with it. "I'm disappointed that every Christmas I have to put up with this when I've contributed so much more to the world than not being in Home Alone," he told Page Six.
The film's staying power is easy to see. Home Alone led to the 1992 sequel Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, again with Macaulay Culkin, Pesci and Stern, followed by later installments and a 2021 Disney+ reboot with new casts, People notes. Columbus himself went on to direct the first two Harry Potter films, a franchise now being rebooted for TV, as Heatline reported in its look at the HBO Harry Potter series cast.
Is a new Home Alone movie in the works?
Nothing has been officially greenlit, but there are signs of interest. People reports that Culkin, 46, has reportedly pitched another sequel to Disney, and Page Six says People reported over the summer that a new Home Alone was in early development. Neither report names a cast or a release date, so both should be treated as unconfirmed.
Columbus is busy elsewhere. People reports he is writing and directing Gremlins 3 and producing Robert Eggers' Werwulf, which opens in theaters on Dec. 25. If you are planning a holiday rewatch instead, Heatline's guide to new movies on Netflix has more options for the season.
