Halloween Candy Recall Affects 13 States Over Milk Allergen

A candy recall involving Crystal Temptations Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs is trending because the product was sold in 13 states, including Ohio and Indiana, with an undeclared milk allergen. The recalled candy was sold through TJ Maxx, Marshalls, HomeGoods and Sierra Trading Post, according to reporting by WKRC, FOX 8 News and People.

What candy was recalled?

The recall covers Crystal Temptations Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs, including products that may also carry Little Temptations branding. The affected candy was packaged in five sizes and styles:

  • 7-ounce acrylic box with paper wrap — style 54077-CHEY
  • 10-ounce plastic bag with header card — style 54040-CHEY
  • 10.5-ounce round plastic jar — style 58008-CHEY
  • 11-ounce plastic bag tied with a tag — style 54083-CHEY
  • 16-ounce designer plastic pouch — style 58089-CHEY

Shoppers should check the brand, product name, package size and style number before deciding whether the candy is part of the recall.

Why was the Halloween candy recalled?

The candy contains whey, a milk-derived ingredient that was not listed on the packaging, according to coverage from People and FOX 8 News. That makes the product a potential health risk for people with milk allergies or other serious dairy sensitivities.

This is an undeclared-allergen recall, not a report of bacterial contamination or a foreign object in the candy. Consumers with milk allergies should not eat the recalled product.

Where was the recalled candy sold?

The recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs were sold at TJ Maxx, Marshalls, HomeGoods and Sierra Trading Post stores in 13 states, according to the published reports. The states are:

  • Arizona
  • California
  • Connecticut
  • Georgia
  • Indiana
  • Massachusetts
  • Nevada
  • New Jersey
  • North Carolina
  • Ohio
  • Texas
  • Virginia
  • Wyoming

The recall is limited to the specified Crystal Temptations products. Candy from other brands or retailers is not identified in the supplied reports as part of this recall.

What should consumers do with the candy?

Do not eat the recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs if you or someone in your household has a milk allergy. Check seasonal candy purchased early for Halloween, particularly products bought at the named TJX-owned retailers in the affected states.

The supplied reports identify the undeclared milk allergen and the affected product, but they do not provide a confirmed total of illnesses or allergic reactions. Because the case remains a product-safety recall, consumers should rely on the package details and retailer or manufacturer instructions before using or disposing of the candy.

When was the recall announced?

The recall was reported on Aug. 31, 2026, as Halloween merchandise began appearing in stores. Seasonal candy bought weeks before Halloween can remain in a pantry until Oct. 31, so consumers should inspect it now rather than waiting until trick-or-treating.

Is the candy recall confirmed or just a rumor?

The recall is confirmed by reports from WKRC, FOX 8 News and People. The reported issue is an undeclared milk allergen in specific Crystal Temptations Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs products sold across 13 states. Claims about illnesses, refunds or additional products should not be treated as confirmed unless supported by a current recall notice or a named retailer or manufacturer statement.